<aside> ๐ŸŽฌ

Vibhor Chandel ยท AI for Professionals

From 20 years of running projects and teams

New videos every Wednesday

YouTube ยท LinkedIn ยท Substack

</aside>

These are the prompts from my video on rehearsing a difficult conversation with ChatGPT. You get a fill-in template for each of the four steps, including the six-part brief, the ASK questions and the three rules for pushing back. You also get the exact prompts I typed in the video for both conversations with Rachel: asking why I didn't get a promotion, and pushing back on a deadline.

<aside> ๐Ÿ“ฅ

Downloads

PromptPack5 - Rehearse a Difficult Conversation (PDF)

PromptPack5 - Rehearse a Difficult Conversation (PDF)

No sample files this time: the video doesn't use any. Both briefs are in the examples below, ready to copy.

</aside>

In this pack

<aside> ๐Ÿ“Œ

Before you start

  1. Open a new chat and turn on Temporary chat. A Temporary chat isn't saved in your history or used to train ChatGPT, and this chat is about your career. If the Temporary chat menu offers "Unpersonalized", pick it, so ChatGPT ignores your memory and custom instructions.
  2. Temporary chat switches off when you click New chat. Turn it on again for every new chat.
  3. Use made-up names, and don't paste in your company's name.
  4. The runs in the video used ChatGPT Plus (Mac app, thinking set to Medium). On other plans or settings, the replies may be worded differently.
  5. Replace everything in [square brackets] with your own details. </aside>

๐Ÿ“ Step 1: Brief the other person

<aside> ๐Ÿ“

If you just type "Pretend you're my boss", ChatGPT plays a boss who gives in far too easily. ChatGPT only knows what you tell it, so give it a short brief about the other person. The brief has six parts:

  1. Who they are.
  2. What happened.
  3. What they really think but keep to themselves, and what kind of question gets them to say it.
  4. How they talk, and how they dodge.
  5. When they give ground.
  6. The rules: stay in character, and keep every reply short.

Prompt 1: the six-part brief (paste it into a new Temporary chat)

Let's role-play a conversation so I can practise. You'll play my [boss].

About you: You're [name], [job title] at [the kind of company, its size and what it sells]. I'm [your job title] on your team. [How long you've been in the role and at the company.]

What happened: [What happened, in two or three sentences.] I've asked you for [number] minutes to talk about it.

What you really think, which you keep to yourself unless I ask [the kind of question that gets it out, for example a calm, specific question about what I should do next time]:

  1. [Their first hidden reason: your best guess]
  2. [Their second hidden reason]

How you talk: You're [kind but vague, or friendly but under pressure]. You use lines like "[a line they always use]", "[another line]" and "[another line]". If I [push back or get upset], [what they do, for example: don't change the decision and don't give in]. [When they give ground, for example: Only give ground when I offer a concrete trade-off: what's in, what's out, and what it costs.]

Rules: Stay in character. Don't coach me or comment on how I'm doing. Reply in 1 to 3 sentences, then wait for me. Start by saying hello and asking [what I wanted to talk about].

<aside> ๐Ÿ’ก

Quick tip. You won't know their real reasons for sure, so write your best guess. Keep those reasons hidden in the brief: getting them out is the job of your questions in step 2.

</aside>

</aside>

๐ŸŽญ Step 2: Rehearse

<aside> ๐ŸŽญ

Open a new Temporary chat, paste your brief, and start the conversation the way you really would. The questions you ask next depend on the conversation.

When you need something, like a promotion or a raise: ASK

A for Advice. Ask for advice about next time, not an explanation of the past.

Prompt 2: the advice question

I'm not here to argue [the decision]. I want [the next one]. What would you advise me to do in the next [six months], so [the next one] is an easy yes?

Trying again in the same chat? Start it with: Can we start again from the top? Same role. This time:

S for Specifics. When you get a general answer, ask for one example. Then ask if there's anything else.

Prompt 3: one example (works as it is, after every general answer)

Can you give me one example of what that would have looked like this year?

Prompt 4: anything else (works as it is)

Is there anything else that would make it an easy yes?

K for Key date. Before the conversation ends, agree on a date when you'll both check how you're doing.

Prompt 5: the key date

Could we check in on my progress on [date]?

When you're pushing back, like on a deadline: three rules

  1. Say no to the date, not to the goal.
  2. Find out what really matters before you offer anything.
  3. Leave with a trade-off and next steps.

Prompt 6: say no to the date

I can't get [the full piece of work] done by [date]. [Why, in one sentence: what's in the way, and what rushing it would cut.]

Prompt 7: find out what really matters

I want to help you deliver on this. What does [the customer] actually need to see on [date]?

Prompt 8: offer a trade-off

Then here's an option. We [deliver the core part] for [the date], and [the rest] by [the later date]. Can we agree on that and tell [the person above them] together this week?

<aside> ๐Ÿ’ก

Quick tip. Ask about next time, not about the past. "Why did Sam get it?" makes your boss defend a decision that's already been made. A question that asks for advice points them at the future instead.

</aside>

</aside>

๐Ÿ“ Step 3: Score the conversation

<aside> ๐Ÿ“

Step out of the role and ask ChatGPT to score you. A number tells you more than a compliment. But asked plainly, ChatGPT is too kind: in the video it gave my second try 9 out of 10 and called it an "Excellent conversation". So make it strict: tell it not to flatter you, who should judge you, and which rules to judge you against.

Prompt 9: the strict score (put in the rules for your kind of conversation)

Step out of the role. Be tough, don't flatter me. Score me out of 10 as a strict [manager] against these rules:

  1. [Rule]
  2. [Rule]
  3. [Rule] One line on what I should change.

Prompt 10: the seven rules for a promotion talk (works as it is, sent after a plain score; it scores both of your tries)

Be tougher. Don't flatter me. Score both rounds as a strict hiring manager who has hired people for 20 years, against these rules:

  1. Stay calm and don't argue the decision.
  2. Ask about next time, not about the person who got it.
  3. Ask for advice, not feedback.
  4. Don't accept the first vague answer. Get the bar, where I stand, and the gap.
  5. Ask for one example.
  6. Ask for an honest read of my chances.
  7. Leave with a check-in date. Then tell me the one line I should change, and what each of your vague lines really meant.

<aside> ๐Ÿ’ก

Quick tip. The score is still ChatGPT's opinion, so treat it as a practice signal, not a grade. Even so, a 7 with reasons is far more useful than a 9 with a compliment.

</aside>

</aside>

๐Ÿ—“๏ธ Step 4: Prep the real conversation

<aside> ๐Ÿ—“๏ธ

Now ChatGPT stops playing the other person and helps you get ready for the real meeting: your opening line, the questions you'll ask, and a short invite to book it.

Prompt 11: prep the real one

Step out of the role. Write my opening line, my three questions, and a two-line meeting invite to my real [boss] for this week. Keep it short and in plain words. Use [Boss] for [her] name.

Leave "Use [Boss]" as it is, so their real name never goes into ChatGPT. Change [her] to his or their if you need to.

<aside> ๐Ÿ’ก

Quick tip. Read the invite before you use it, and send it from your own email or calendar. Then book the real conversation.

</aside>

</aside>

๐Ÿ” Same four steps, any hard conversation

<aside> ๐Ÿ”

The video runs the same four steps on a very different conversation: Rachel wants your team to finish a feature a month early, because she's already promised it to the CEO.

  1. Step 1: keep the brief, and change only the lines about the situation.
  2. Step 2: you're not asking for something, you're pushing back, so use the three rules instead of ASK (prompts 6 to 8).
  3. Step 3: score yourself against those three rules (prompt 9).
  4. Step 4: prep the real conversation, just like before (prompt 11).

<aside> ๐Ÿ’ก

Quick tip. You can use the same four steps for other hard conversations too, like asking for a raise or giving someone tough feedback.

</aside>

</aside>


Examples

Example 1: Asking why I didn't get the promotion

Example 2: Pushing back on a deadline